Pony Express Pizza | Our Story
Your neighborhood slice on 3rd Street
Pony Express Pizza sits right on 3rd Street in Henderson, Kentucky — a straightforward neighborhood pizzeria that's here to make a good pie and keep people coming back.
A Henderson original
Pony Express Pizza has been feeding Henderson for years — a neighborhood staple with house-made dough and a menu worth coming back to.
The promise: a good pie
Pony Express Pizza is built on a simple idea: show up, make a good pie, and deliver on that every time. No frills, no gimmicks — just a focused, honest pizza experience.
Come as you are
Order at the counter, grab a seat, and feel at home — no reservations needed, no occasion required.
